He Gave Up a Summit for a Life
16 בנובמבר 2026
A Dutch climber lost consciousness at Camp 2 on Ama Dablam. Among those who stayed with him all night was Israeli Tzachi Miara, the only one to give up his summit.
On the night of 27 to 28 October 2026, at Camp 2 on Ama Dablam in Nepal, at about 6,000 metres, climbers on their way to their own summit stopped to save a life. A 25-year-old Dutch climber had lost consciousness there, and they stayed by his side all night, until a rescue helicopter arrived at first light.
One of them was an Israeli climber, Tzachi Miara. He reached Camp 2 after months of training and preparation, with the summit right above him. In the morning the others went on to the summit. Tzachi was the only one who decided to give it up.
And here the question that has followed the climbing world for years comes up again: a summit or a human life.
What happened at Camp 2
The Dutch climber, K., was on an organised expedition. According to The Tourism Times, he summited, at 6,812 metres, on 27 October with two other climbers and their guides. On the way down he lost consciousness at Camp 2 and could not go on. His two companions continued safely to Camp 1.
That evening, Hungarian climber Xenia Santha and her partner Paul Clarke reached the camp. They quickly understood it was a matter of life or death, and put off the summit attempt they had planned for that day. "That night, a person's life became more important than the summit," Santha said.
The Israeli who gave up the summit
One of the climbers who took part in the effort to save K. that night was Israeli climber Tzachi Miara. He too came with a summit of his own and months of training, preparation and expense behind him. But while the others went on to the summit after the helicopter flew K. out, Tzachi was the only one who decided to give it up.
It is easy to talk about values at home. It is much harder to choose them at 6,000 metres, at night, exhausted, when the goal you worked for so long is right above you. That is the choice Tzachi made that night.
Thank you, Tzachi
It is easy to be a good climber when everything goes to plan. What counts is what you do when someone else needs you. Tzachi is an example of how to behave in the mountains, and we simply want to say: thank you for representing Israeli climbers in the Himalaya in the best way there is.
A long night beside one tent
For hours the climbers tried to get help, with almost no signal. Through K.'s phone they reached his mother, and at the same time spoke with base camp, with other expedition companies and with his insurer.
Every few minutes they checked his pulse and breathing, and when he coughed they turned him on his side. Santha and Clarke had no sleeping bag and very little food. Santha called it "a brutal night". The guides of his expedition never left him.
In the middle of the night, a Sherpa from the guiding team set off. He climbed down from Camp 2 to Camp 1, in the dark and on fixed ropes, collected oxygen and climbed back up with it. At that altitude the air holds about half the oxygen it does at sea level, and a helicopter can only come in daylight.
The morning: a helicopter, and in the end a summit too
At about 6:30 in the morning on 28 October a rescue helicopter arrived. The pilot, Captain Laurenz Elsasser, flew K. to Lukla on oxygen, and from there he was taken to a hospital in Kathmandu. According to reports, he is stable.
Two hours later, after a night with almost no sleep, Santha and Clarke set off for the summit on their own, with no guide and no Sherpa, ahead of incoming snow. At 17:18 they stood on top, and Santha became the first Hungarian woman to summit Ama Dablam.
A summit or a human life
The night at Camp 2 is not the first time this question has come up in the mountains. On Everest in May 2006, British climber David Sharp died after dozens of climbers passed him. Eleven days later, American guide Dan Mazur gave up the summit to save Australian climber Lincoln Hall, who had been left for dead. Hall survived.
What to take from that night
The summit will always wait. A person's life does not. The decision to help is not made at Camp 2, it is made long before, when you understand that the summit is only part of the journey. And that night showed one more thing: when something goes wrong at altitude, what counts is who is beside you.
On the HighAir Ama Dablam expedition every climber has a personal Sherpa guide, and the plan has spare days for weather and for nights like this one. And before you go, make sure your insurance covers climbing up to 6,812 metres, including helicopter rescue and evacuation.
לכל הפרטים על משלחת אמא דאבלם שלנו
Frequently asked questions
Who is the Israeli climber who took part in the Ama Dablam rescue?
Israeli climber Tzachi Miara was one of the climbers who fought for the Dutch climber's life at Camp 2 on the night of 27 to 28 October 2026, and was the only one of them who gave up his summit.
What happened at Camp 2 on Ama Dablam in October 2026?
On 27 October 2026 a 25-year-old Dutch climber lost consciousness at Camp 2 on the way down from the summit. Climbers at the camp stayed with him all night, and a Sherpa went down to Camp 1 in the night to bring oxygen. In the morning he was evacuated by helicopter, and he is stable. Israeli climber Tzachi Miara was the only one of them who gave up the summit.
How is a climber rescued from Camp 2 on Ama Dablam?
Above Camp 1 there is no landing place for a helicopter, so an evacuation from Camp 2 and higher is done on a long line hanging under the helicopter, in daylight and in weather that allows flying.
How much does a helicopter rescue on Ama Dablam cost?
According to an insurer quoted by Explorersweb, a long-line rescue from Camp 2 and above can cost about 18,000 dollars or more.
What insurance do I need for an Ama Dablam expedition?
Travel and medical insurance that explicitly covers climbing up to 6,812 metres, including helicopter rescue and evacuation. Check this in the policy itself before you buy.
Does the HighAir Ama Dablam expedition include a personal guide?
Yes. Every climber has a personal Sherpa guide, and the local guiding team leads the expedition in English. The plan includes spare days for weather.